By Ray Pride Pride@moviecitynews.com
Why We Fight and David Denby has always been at war with Oceania
Doc-maker Eugene Jarecki articulates a thing or two about Why We Fight to Rob Nelson in the VOICE: “There’s a tendency to lay all our problems at the feet of George W. Bush, to want to see him as taking a radical departure from the traditions of U.S. foreign policy. But Bush wasn’t born overnight: He’s the product of decades of movement by this country away from its origins and ideals, and toward something more aggressive, more arrogant, more imperial. The Iraq war certainly isn’t the first time that the reasons we were given to go to war have turned out not to be the real reasons why we went. Ultimately I think it’s a political distraction for us to be obsessed with Bush or any other single figure. The larger forces that the film examines are those—including the military- industrial complex—that are undoing the very fabric of the democracy we’re fighting for. It’s what Eisenhower meant when he said, “We must avoid destroying from within that which we are trying to protect from without.” It’s an articulate position, even before reading David Denby‘s pissy notice in The New Yorker: “Isn’t it time to retire the collage method of making documentaries? A phrase or two clipped out of some policy expert’s discourse, followed by a bit of stock footage of jet fighters lined up in rows, followed by some candy-sucking kids… and, wham!, you’ve got an indictment of American militarism and imperialism. Except you don’t; you don’t have much of anything but tawdry film-editing technique… Why We Fight argues that we are at war in Iraq because we have been at war, someplace or other, on some pretext or other, under every Administration since Harry Truman was President, and we have to be perpetually at war in order to stoke what President Eisenhower, in his famous 1961 farewell address, named the “military-industrial complex.” … In order to be great a documentary must discover something…. A documentary filmmaker, at the least, must be a journalist seeking to unearth, and not a collagist who assembles miscellaneous footage in order to support what he already believes.”