By David Poland poland@moviecitynews.com
20W20: Best Actor Chart, Oct 23, 2011
10/23/11 Charts
Picture | Actor | Supporting Actor | Actress | Supporting Actress
BEST ACTOR
|
|
Picture |
Comment
|
The Field | |
Jean Dujardin The Artist |
One of France’s biggest stars is about to become one of Hollywood’s favorite stars. A win could be dependent on his ability to charm in English this January. |
George Clooney The Descendents |
He’s Clooney. Nice performance. Nothing very new… except a couple of lines on his face. |
Michael Fassbender Shame |
How do you follow up a legendary performance like Hunger? With the Oscar nomination he deserved and deserves? The film will challenge Academy members, but could it be a badge of honor for them to be sophisticated enough to embrace it, a ;a Last Tango? |
Leonardo DiCaprio J Edgar |
Ads have gotten the aging issue out of the way. DiCaprio is actually an underrated actor. |
Gary Oldman Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy |
It’s a(nother) great performance, but it’s an ensemble film and he’s still not 100% out of the doghouse. |
Michael Shannon Take Shelter |
If you thought he was something in Revolutionary Road, see this film. And thanks to Sony Classics putting the DVD out to voters early, people do seem to be seeing it. |
Daniel Craig The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo |
This one really depends on the film’s success. In the first incarnation of this material, this role was well played, but kind of the expositional character. We’ll see. |
Jeremy Irvine War Horse |
As the movie goes, so goes this loveable newcomer. |
Ryan Gosling Drive |
Apparently, RG’s going to throw all of his weight into this one. But last year, with Blue Valentine, that still meant a lot of hide and go seek. He can have an Oscar nod and be a mega-star. Does he want it? |
Tom Hanks Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close |
He’s Hanks. Will he jerk our tears? Could, from what I hear, be in Supporting… but will probably stay away to give Von Sydow room. |
Matt Damon We Bought A Zoo |
Always excellent… never rewarded enough. Depends on the film. |
Brad Pitt The Tree of Life |
He was terrific. But not likely to happen in a very crowded field. |
Brad Pitt Moneyball |
And he’s crowding himself here too. It was really the first big awards movie to open this year. And he was perfect. But will it linger? |
Woody Harrelson Rampart |
He’s chewing the scenery so hard that he’s worn down his bicuspids, but somehow, he makes it look smooth and effortless. One of our most underrated actors… but this will be a hard row to hoe. |
Viggo Mortensen A Dangerous Method |
Viggo as The Uber-Mensch Jew. But he digs right in and brings all the muscle to it that Cronenberg and Hampton were looking for. But not sure he can overcome the field. |
Tom Hardy Warrior |
One of the rising greats… a real man… completely Brandoesque, but you;d never know it from Tinker Tailor and other roles. Amazing work here with very few words and a ton of feelings. It shoulda been a contender. |
Ryan Gosling The Ides of March |
The Great Gosling holds the room next to some of the best in the game. But soft reviews and business may have killed this one’s Oscar dreams. |
Are they really gonna push Pitt in Lead for Tree Of Life?
Anton Yelchin is being forgotten for his rolein Like Crazy and has a better shot than Craig has for DragonTattoo- miniscule but possible
For Oldman, what does “he’s not 100% out of the doghouse” mean? Just wondering the context/story.
Unless the movie is significantly different from the book, it’s hard to imagine how Hanks could be a lead — it’s not even a Marge Gunderson-sized lead. And Jason: Conservative, mouthy, blah blah.
Is Gosling really putting all his weight for Drive (a big hit in France!)? Where have you hear that I am just curious. Does he campaign or did he campaign in the past? I have heard both yes and no?
Dujardin is a well known comic, not so much of a serious actor in France. The Artist just opened in France and it’s doing well. But he’s sure to charm the academy members no?
@Chris, thanks.
Tom Hanks doesn’t have the screen time in EL&IC to be considered for Best Actor. He has less screen time than Von Sydow, who is definitely EL&IC’s best chance in Supporting contention.
I also thought the studio is pushing Brad Pitt for supporting in Tree of Life.