Posts Tagged ‘bitter feast’

The DVD Wrap: Machete, Dinner for Schmucks, Easy A, Howl … and more

Tuesday, January 4th, 2011

Machete

In this insanely hyperactive action flick, Robert Rodriguez delivers on the promise made in the faux “Mexsploitation” trailer that accompanied Grindhouse. It would be folly to attempt any synopsis of Machete, except to recall that Danny Trejo’s character is a former Mexican federal agent, seeking to exact revenge on the American druglord (Steven Seagal) who is responsible for the deaths of his wife and child. Since he’s in Texas, anyway, though, Machete accepts a contract to assassinate a rabidly anti-immigration senator (Robert De Niro). In fact, the assignment is a set-up.

Ostensibly, Machete has as large a target on his back as the senator. Unlike some movie anti-heroes, however, Machete isn’t invincible. If it weren’t for the assistance of some hard-core Chicanas (Jessica Alba, Michelle Rodriguez) and a small army of low-riding homeboys, the local rednecks might have chopped him up with his own machetes and served him for dinner at the next Minuteman banquet.

Some critics have suggested that the trailer was the movie, only shorter. That’s probably true for fair-weather fans of grindhouse nouveau, but, loyal followers of Rodriguez and Tarantino’s oeuvre will undoubtedly have a blast. The action is non-stop, thoroughly goofy and well over the top. Like most contemporary grindhouse epics, too, appearances by actors familiar from other genres add much diversionary fun.

Besides De Niro, Alba, Rodriguez and Segal, who hasn’t appeared in a theatrical picture in years, the cast includes Don Johnson, Lindsay Lohan, Jeff Fahey and Rodriguez regulars Cheech Marin, Daryl Sabara, Tom Savini, Michael Parks and Rose McGowan. (Machete is co-directed by his fave editor, Ethan Maniquis.) It’s Trejo’s show, however, and his machetes of mass destruction are all one needs to recommend it. The only bonus feature of note is the deleted scenes.

__________________________________________________

Dinner for Schmucks: Blu-ray

My limited knowledge of Yiddish slang precludes me from parsing the difference between “schmuck” and the more mundane, “moron,” at least for the purposes of this review. For as long as I can remember, the use of the word “schmuck” in mixed company was discouraged, if only because it also meant “penis.” Dinner for Schmucks was adapted from Francis Veber’s more subtle pleasure, The Dinner Game. In contemporary Hollywood, subtlety is for suckers.

The basic concept works for both pictures, though. A group of self-satisfied friends meet on regular basis for dinner. Each is required to bring a guest so insufferably pompous, maddeningly boorish or terminally stupid that he’s crowned that week’s prince of fools. This premise wouldn’t amount to much if, at some point in the movie, the fools didn’t turn the tables on their mean-spirited hosts, begging the question as to who’s the real schmuck. And, of course, this is exactly what happens.

Steve Carell has made a career playing these kinds of self-absorbed doofuses, and his nebbish IRS agent, Barry, is custom made for exhibition in the dinner game. Among other irritating habits, Barry collects dead mice for future use in historical dioramas. Paul Rudd plays Tim, an ambitious executive whose boss (Bruce Greenwood) demands he prove his mettle by participating in the game. Tim knows the hapless diorama maker is his ticket to promotion after running into him with his car while Barry’s picking up a dead mouse in the street. Little does Tim know how stiff the competition for the dunce cap will be.

Director Jay Roach doesn’t trust the material enough to forgo a clunky romantic contretemps between Tim and his spectacularly beautiful girlfriend, Julie (Stephanie Szostak). It provides more evidence of Barry’s clumsiness, but, otherwise, prolongs the wait for the dinner party. That said, Dinner for Schmucks is far more entertaining than other recent boys-will-boys comedies, all of which are founded on a stupidity contest of one form or another. Carell gets ample support from Zach Galifianakis, Jemaine Clement and Kristen Schaal (Flight of the Conchords), Lucy Punch and Ron Livingston. And, yes, the entertainment provided by the so-called schmucks is hilarious. The hi-def edition arrives with the featurettes, “The Biggest Schmucks in the World,” “The Men Behind the Mouseterpieces,” “Meet the Winners” and “Schmuck Ups,” as well as deleted scenes.

__________________________________________________

Easy A: Blu-ray

In the absence of any better ideas, some screenwriters have found success by adapting classic works of literature for teenage audiences. Cruel Intentions was inspired by Les liaisons dangereuses; Emma begat Clueless; Shakespeare provided the fodder for Romeo+ Juliet, West Side Story, O, 10 Things I Hate About You and She’s the Man. Will Gluck’s wonderful teen rom-com, Easy A, was informed, at least, by The Scarlet Letter.

Rising superstar Emma Stone plays Olive, a hip, if little-noticed high school girl, who sees her life paralleling Hester Prynne’s in the Nathaniel Hawthorne novel. East Ojai High School may be the only public school in America where virginity is still something to which boys and girls aspire. In an effort to avoid one embarrassing revelation, Olive inadvertently sparks a rumor that leads her fellow students to believe she’s promiscuous.

After accepting more than her fair share of undeserved humiliation, Olive decides to profit from the misconception. In return for money, she allows closeted gay kids and other dweebs to use her as a beard. Despite the windfall, the ruse complicates matters with the only boy she wants to impress. Stone delivers writer Bert V. Royal’s waspish dialogue with great moxie and sympathy for Olive. The other characters are allowed to get in some licks of their own, as well.

I’m far from being a teenager, but I think Easy A was one of the best films of 2010, regardless of genre, and Stone’s performance is worthy of an Oscar nomination. True Grit star Hailee Steinfeld may already have nailed down the spot annually allotted an actress playing a teen role, though. Here, Stone gets plenty of help from Stanley Tucci and Patricia Clarkson, as her bemused parents, hunky Penn Badgley, snarky Amanda Bynes, Thomas Haden Church, Lisa Kudrow and Malcolm McDowell. The Blu-ray package adds a great deal of bonus material, including commentary with Gluck and Stone; a pop-up trivia quiz; BD-Live connectivity; a making-of documentary; gag reel; audition footage; and featurettes, “The School of Pop Culture: Movies of the ’80s” and “Vocabulary of Hilarity.”

__________________________________________________

Howl

Allen Ginsberg’s great primal scream of a poem, Howl, is at the center of Rob Epstein and Jeff Friedman’s film of the same title. As epic poetry goes, Howl is a million times less cinematic than, say, Beowulf, The Odyssey, The Canterbury Tales or, even, The Cat in the Hat. The filmmakers, though, use the debut reading of the poem as a stepping stone to other aspects of Ginsberg’s amazing life.

First, they dramatize publisher and book-seller Lawrence Ferlinghetti’s 1957 obscenity trial. We’re also introduced to fellow Beats muses, Jack Kerouac and Neal Cassady, who played key roles in the development of the poem. James Franco portrays Ginsberg with an eerie specificity, as he alternately reads Howl before an audience and tells the story of his life and coming-out to an interviewer. Finally, for better or worse, the poem has been animated by art director Eric Drooker. (It could easily exist as a stand-alone short film.) That’s a lot of material to stuff into a 90-minute bag, but Epstein and Friedman manage to pull it off in nimble style.

In our collective memory of him, Ginsberg sometimes resembles a harmless hippie Santa Claus, still worshiped by the counterculture as a founding father and accepted by the mainstream as a symbol of America’s “tolerance” of oddballs and rebels. As Howl points out, however, Ginsberg and his poem were the furthest things from mainstream in the mid-1950s. The Beats represented repudiation of post-war complacency and conformity, and, along with Kerouac, Ginsberg was its most visible diplomat. He openly celebrated his homosexuality at a time when it was illegal in most states and feared by a majority of Americans.

Beats and beatniks were ridiculed in the media for their shaggy appearance and despised by philistines for their taste in everything from shoes (sandals) to music (be-bop). Howl captures all that and more in documentary-like fashion. Franco is nothing short of terrific and he gets excellent support from John Hamm, Mary-Louise Parker, Jeff Daniels, David Straithairn, Alessandro Nivola, Treat Williams, Bob Balaban, Jon Prescott and Aaron Tveit. The bonus material adds several making-of featurettes and backgrounders, including a reading of Howl by a much older Ginsberg.

__________________________________________________

Beautiful Kate

Apparently, Hollywood has a problem with incest. The negative reflex explains why it took nearly 30 years for Newton Thornburg’s perfectly adaptable novel, Beautiful Kate, to make the move from page to screen, and why it took an Aussie production company to make it. After Rachel Ward and Bryan Brown acquired the rights to the story, she moved it from Chicago to the “bush,” in Australia’s Flinder Ranges.

Its protagonist is a young writer, Ned, who’s been asked by his younger sister to return home to pay a final visit with his estranged father. Ned arrives in the company of a pretty bimbo, Toni, whose presence disturbs the uneasy calm enough to bring the family’s dysfunctional history back into focus. Through flashbacks, we learn of Ned’s illicit relationship with his sexually aggressive twin sister and how it resulted in a pair of tragic deaths. Even on his death bed, the old man is a brute. He minimizes everything in Ned’s life and blames him for the collapse of the family ranch. It opens wounds that never completely healed.

One of the most popular actors in Australia, Ward wrote and directed Beautiful Kate. By transferring the story to a remote outpost in the middle of nowhere, she was able to show how such isolation impacted on the lives of characters making the transition from childhood to sexual maturity surrounded by a herd of randy sheep. As twins, Ned and Kate already were closer than the average brother and sister, if only because their father’s ugly behavior forced them to take shelter in each other’s arms. To reveal any more would spoil too much of the movie’s surprises.

Ben Mendelsohn and Sophie Lowe are quite good as the star-crossed twins, as are Brown, Rachel Griffiths and Maeve Dermody in important roles. Ward shows great promise as a director of features. She succeeds in capturing the sense of desolation felt by the young characters, while also showcasing some of Australia’s great beauty. There are deleted scenes, interviews and background material.

__________________________________________________

Ticking Clock: Blu-ray
Bitter Feast
Gun: Blu-ray
Haunting of Amelia

The new year brings with it a flood of direct-to-DVD titles that share a lust for blood and bizarre plot twists.

In Ticking Clock, Cuba Gooding Jr. plays an investigative reporter who specializes in exposing police ineptitude in murder cases. This doesn’t endear the writer to police when people around him start dropping like flies and he’s the most likely suspect. We know, of course, that the reporter didn’t commit any of the grotesque crimes, but become as suspicious as the police when the Gooding’s character argues that time-travel is the only logical way the real killer could have gone undetected for so long a time. It also explains how the reporter is the only person who can prevent even more murders. A word to the wise: mixing time-travel and mystery-solving only works when it involves Sherlock Holmes.

If you’ve ever wondered why more critics aren’t attacked by the victims of their snarky wordplay and harmful condemnations, Bitter Feast is the movie for you. James Le Gros plays a chef whose cuisine has been attacked unmercifully by a bitter food blogger and stands to lose his TV gig and restaurant because of the put-downs. In response, the chef kidnaps the writer and forces him to meet food challenges that would be simple, if it weren’t for the handcuffs and knife wounds. The worse the dishes are prepared, the more torture is inflicted on the writer. Look for celebrity chef Mario Batali in a brief performance.

Curtis “50 Cent” Jackson and Val Kilmer make a formidable team in Gun, an extremely loud shoot-em-up set in Detroit. Jackson plays a thuggish gangsta’ out to control the illicit gun trade in the upper Midwest, while Kilmer is an ex-con looking for payback in the death of his wife. Director Jerry Terrero nicely captures the icy Rust Belt setting and the results of unharnessed fire power. Jackson’s story breaks little new territory, but moves along snappily. Less convincing is the thug’s boss, a sexy blond improbably portrayed by 23-year-old AnnaLynne McCord. To the directors go the spoils.

Haunting of Amelia (a.k.a., The Other Side of the Tracks) is a supernatural romance that can’t seem to decide whether it wants to be scary or sentimental. As such, it more closely resembles a Halloween special on the Lifetime network than a full-blown mystery or horror flick.

Ten years after a tragic train accident killed his girlfriend, restaurant employee Josh (Brendan Fehr) suddenly finds himself surrounded by people from his past. The anniversary of the accident coincides with a school reunion, so at least one of the appearances can be explained. The other visitor, an attractive brunette 10 years younger than Josh, takes a few more seconds to figure out. Haunting of Amelia benefits mostly from its woodsy Connecticut setting.

__________________________________________________

Case 39

The always-welcome Renée Zellweger plays a social worker, Emily, assigned to the case of a little girl who was brutalized by her psycho stepparents. Too traumatized by the experience for another placement, the kid, Lilith (Jodelle Ferland), begs Emily to assume the role of foster mom. Predictably, little Lilith then begins to exhibit the same sorts of traits that might have caused her former guardians to stick her into an oven and turn on the gas.

Case 39 looks good, but, apart from some hideous deaths, there’s nothing really new here. Zellweger is joined by such fine actors as Ian McShane, Bradley Cooper, Cynthia Stevenson and Callum Rennie. The package includes 18 deleted scenes and featurettes on the special visual effects.

__________________________________________________

Big Love: The Complete Fourth Season
Mannix: The Fourth Season

There’s thin pickin’s on the TV-to-DVD front this week. HBO sends out the fourth-season package of Big Love, during which Bill saved his son from bird-smuggling Mormon kidnappers, got deeper involved with casino intrigue and ran for political office. The polygamist’s decision to out himself in public causes much tension among the wives and prompts them to think and act for themselves, for once. The new season starts this month.

As played by Mike Connors (born, Krekor Ohanian), Armenian-American P.I. Joe Mannix was one of the most popular crimefighters in television history. This might have had something to do with the fact that he seemed like an average Joe, drove hot cars and got beat up a lot. His pretty African-American assistant, Peggy Fair (Gail Fisher), also is frequently put into harm’s way. The new set represents the fourth season in an eight-year run on CBS.

Wilmington on Movies: The Chicago International Film Festival, Red, Conviction … and more

Thursday, October 14th, 2010

The 46th Chicago International Film Festival

The Chicago Film Festival was the first film fest I ever attended, and it only whetted my appetite for other fests, and other Chicagos, to come.

It was 1970, and the festival’s two Honorees in that Vietnam War-torn year were Howard Hawks and George Stevens. (Great picks.) Since Hawks was (then and now) one of my all-time favorite directors, I traveled eagerly by car the relatively short distance between my college town, Madison, Wisconsin, and the Windy City, to see him in person. Joe McBride was there too; and we’d soon be embroiled in the John Ford book, which, for better or worse, kind of rolled the dice and cast my lot from then on as a movie critic, instead of the actor and fiction writer I’d always wanted to be. (Still do, in fact.)

Now, let me tell you, that was one hell of a great experience for a movie-drunk twenty-something from Wisconsin. The theatre was packed and Hawks was introduced on the stage, first by festival founder-artistic director (then and now) Michael Kutza and interviewed by Charles Flynn, co-editor (with Todd McCarthy) of the anthology Kings of the B’s and one of a prime Chicago movie buff wild bunch of that era (and afterwards) that included McCarthy, Myron Meisel, Dave Kehr, Henry Sheehan and many others.

I still remember the way Hawks looked on stage: 75, trim, tall, healthy, white-haired (as he‘d been since his heyday as the “Silver Fox of Brentwood“), impeccably dressed in suit and tie, and very quiet, poised and unflappable. As I recall, he reacted to Charles’s fulsome intro with a little impatience. Then he launched into his show.

Hawks tended to tell the same stories over and over again — in life as in his movies — and the tales he told Flynn and the audience that day were mostly the same ones I’d already read in Peter Bogdanovich‘s “Movie” interview — and mostly the same ones he‘d tell me, several years later, when I drove up with my friend “Little Michael” Shovers to interview him at his house on Palm Springs. Not his fault. I guess we tended to ask the same questions. And, as with his movies, he figured out a way to spin or re-spin them all that kept them fresh and funny. Joe later wrote up the whole audience discussion in an article for “Sight and Sound” called “Hawks Talks.”

Think of it: Not only were Howard Hawks (and Stevens) still alive, still able to share their memories with the movie-lovers who loved their films, the cinephiles who’d grown up on Rio Bravo and Shane, His Girl Friday and Woman of the Year, The Big Sleep and A Place in the Sun. But so were Orson Welles and Billy Wilder and Otto Preminger and Vincente Minnelli and Abel Gance and Satyajit Ray and Robert Wise and Don Siegel and Luchino Visconti and Rainer Werner Fassbinder and Francois Truffaut (to name just some of the directors, and none of the many stars, from Gloria Swanson to Liza Minnelli, who came too) who either came before or eventually, made it to the stages of the Chicago Film Festival, to be introduced by Kutza and others, and to share their stories with passionate movie lovers who loved to hear them. Even if it wasn‘t for the first time.

Chicago’s fest debuted in 1964, with Bette Davis, King Vidor and Stanley Kramer as the guests. And this year, it was still here: the 46th Chicago Film Festival, all of them hosted by Kutza, who has now (almost) outlasted two Mayoral Dick (or Rich) Daleys and become as much a Chicago fixture as, say, The Art Institute, Tribune Tower or Wrigley Field. He still has a lot of snap and wit, a lot of stories — some of which I’ve heard before — and a grin that won’t quit. The 2010 Chicago honorees included Ron Howard, Forest Whitaker, Guillermo Del Toro and Paula Wagner.

So once again, I’m going from theatre to theatre, wearing my Festival credentials (with my head shot) on a lanyard again, and I’m also wearing the last Chicago Film Festival credential card ever issued (with her head shot) for my mother Edna, the Singin’ in the Rain-loving lady whom Kutza always greeted and treated like the queen she was, and who once told me that going to film festivals and galas were the happiest times of her life.

The happiest of mine too. From Howard Hawks on. (Howard, tell us the one about how you and your wife Slim picked Lauren Bacall from some fashion shots for To Have and Have Not, and how you how you thought her Have Not costar Bogie was the most insolent guy on the screen, but you intended to make her even more insolent than Bogie, and how they fell in love….)

All the following movies were fest choices this year. Red and Conviction open their runs Friday.
__________________________________________________

Red (Two and a Half Stars)

U. S.: Robert Schwentke, 2010

The name “Red” stands for “Retired: Extremely Dangerous,” which is the legend stamped on the files of Bruce Willis, as 50-something Black Op specialist Frank Moses — and also on the files of his longtime colleague/buddies, played by top-chop actors Helen Mirren, John Malkovich and Morgan Freeman.

In addition, it’s the title of a long comic book, a.k.a. graphic novel series, by Warren Ellis and Cully Hammer, all about old retired C. I. A. pals uncovering plots and going on rampages, and of the cleaned-up, fairly entertaining and likable, but basically kind of silly action thriller that director Robert Schwentke (The Time Traveler’s Wife) and writers Jon and Erick Hoeber have made from it.

Mind you, I like all these actors — and many of the others in Red — quite a lot. They should always be working, and in roles worthy of them (or at least in roles that pay well, like this one). But Red‘s script is the same old stuff, the same old malarkey, only with an older, better, brainier cast.

And listen, if I have to read one more review about how this is a movie especially for AARP members, or the geriatric set, or card-carrying Medicare moviegoers, or old folks, I think I’ll throw my walker at them. Give me a break. What do these clowns want, a life spent perusing nothing but Jesse Eisenberg, Michael Cera, or Hannah Montana movies? (Gauging from the response to The Social Network, part of that may actually happen.) Should we look at stuff like the Transformers and say that they’re movies targeted for the young (dumb) punk audience? Even if they obviously are?

Well, you get my drift. Any movie that casts all the above actors — and others here like Brian Cox, Richard Dreyfuss, James Remar, and for the love of God, 93-year-old Ernie Borgnine as Henry, the C. I. A. records keeper — maybe deserves a medal. But it also lays itself open for ageist cracks and youth-crazed dopey biases, which are far too rabid in movies and TV these days anyway.

Red tries to attack those biases, make fun of them. But there’s a problem. Like many modern movies with older actors, this picture has them playing too constantly young and spunky (Freeman as the more vulnerable 80-year-old Tom Matheson honorably excepted), when they’d be more effective playing older, more vulnerable but smarter (like John Wayne, Robert Mitchum and Arthur Hunnicutt in El Dorado).

The idea seems to be that Frank should show us he’s as good as he ever was, better than the young punks in his face, and the older creeps behind them. And he is, but maybe his superiority would be better shown in different ways than this show seems to value: killing a bunch of bad guys who have superior firepower and government backing, and screwing young women. Especially when Helen Mirren is around.

The plot has Frank falling for young Sarah Ross (Mary Louise Parker) a chatty phone operator at his C.I.A. pension number — and then nearly getting rubbed out at his home by a hit squad that seems to be under the command of fashionable C.I.A. stud William Cooper (Karl Urban). So Frank grabs Sarah, and takes off on a transcontinental, multi-location jaunt/chase to find and warn and recruit his old pals and colleagues: Freeman as the wry-smiling Matheson (who’s actually in an old folks’ home), Mirren as two-gun Victoria (who can practically juggle automatics, and recovers almost instantly from bloody torso shots), and Malkovich as Marvin Boggs, the recluse/weirdo of the bunch. (It’s another of Malkovich‘s “Don’t-rile-him-he’s-crazy” roles.)

Along for support is the gang’s old friendly antagonist, and Victoria’s From Russia with Love ex, Ivan Simonov (Brian Cox). And lurking in the background are Robert Stanton (Julian McMahon), a hypocritical Vice President, and far-right Presidential candidate, who apparently hasn’t yet gotten his automatic candidate/host slot on Fox News.

Also lurking and smirking is evil arrogant rich bastard Alexander Dunning — played by Richard Dreyfuss, whom Dick Cheney might accuse of a Tina Fey job, or of Sarah Palinizing him. Jesse Eisenberg seems a natural for the missing part of the young C.I.A. trainee or Internet expose reporter, who defects to Frank’s gang, but maybe they figured they didn’t need him, with Parker around. Or maybe they‘d already made enough changes to the source — which I haven’t read.

The movie is fast and pretty funny and it gets around. It’s not too good, thanks to the script, but I liked the company, and you probably will too.

SPOILER ALERT

Still, let me make a suggestion. Red would be a much better, punchier show, if it didn’t make lovebirds-on-the-run all the way through, of Frank and Sarah, but instead had made Sarah a villainess, had her betray Frank, and had her join up with the bad guys — and if Frank salved his wounds by hooking up with a willing Victoria, taking her away from Ivan. (Tovarich!) That’s a better match than Frank-Sarah. The movie also needs a big, crazy villain to counter-balance Malkovich’s wild man Boggs. (Gary Sinise, maybe.) And the cinematography’s a little drab, maybe on purpose. But hey, thanks everybody, just for being there — and for bringing Ernie Borgnine with you. (“What do you wanna do tonight, Henry?” “I don’t know, what do you wanna do tonight, Marty?“ “I don‘t know…”)
__________________________________________________

Conviction” (Three Stars)

U. S.: Tony Goldwyn, 2010

Movies about travesties of justice always get my blood boiling — and I felt a lot of the old simmer and rage while watching Conviction. (This whole review, by the way, is potentially SPOILER ALERT, but you probably know the story anyway, and if you don’t, knowing it won’t really hurt the movie much. But, if you want, quit reading here. See the picture anyway.)

Tony Goldwyn’s real-life crime and courtroom saga, which is a very good job all around, is about the unjust incarceration (for murder) of a reckless working-class guy named Kenny Waters (Sam Rockwell), who was suspected of killing a lady friend, got framed for the murder by a vindictive cop, Nancy Taylor (Melissa Leo), a bully who didn’t like his manner, and got him sent up for life — but whose determined, loving, indefatigable sister, Betty Anne (Hilary Swank) refused to give up on him.

Instead, Betty Anne studied law, became a lawyer, dug up every record, re-interviewed the witnesses, and finally after nearly two decades, and after her own family and marriage fell apart, connected with Barry Scheck (Peter Gallagher) and Peter Neufeld’s Innocence Project, which uses DNA evidence to clear wrongly incarcerated, even condemned, prisoners. It was still a chore, because, as in many cases like this, the police and the prosecutors don’t like to admit mistakes.

The movie should make you happy on several levels. It shows us believably, that love counts, that the little guy can beat back even the most stubborn abuses of power, and that no matter how huge the task and long the odds, the heart and brain may find a way.

Swank plays Betty Anne with just the right mix of guts, slightly pain-in-the-ass grit and raw devotion — and though I hesitate to say it so semi-schmaltzily, she creates a character here both achingly real and a real role model. Swank has probably gotten her quota of Oscars for a while. But Rockwell, who gets both the good and bad sides of Kenny — he makes us like him, makes us understand why Betty Anne loves him, but also shows why he can be dangerous — is worth the prize talk he’s generated. I just hope he’s nominated in the lead actor Oscar category, which is winnable for him, and not supporting actor, a seemingly more probable slot, but a game-plan that’s not really fair to most of the other supporting candidates — then forced to compete against this movie’s lead male role, against something so deep and rich, and, as any actor will tell you, the best acting part this movie has to offer.

Elsewhere, Melissa Leo (a powerhouse in Frozen River) is a chillingly blank-eyed Officer Taylor, and Minnie Driver is the best, toughest, warmest gal-pal Betty Anne, or this movie, could have. The smaller roles are equally high caliber — like Gallagher as the sharp-eyed Scheck, or Juliette Lewis in one of her sleazy-sexy roles as a bad witness. And the movie has that actor-friendly, perfectly staged Sidney Lumet feel I’m sure Goldwyn wanted.

Back in 1999, Goldwyn made a moving family drama called A Walk on the Moon, set in 1969 in the Catskills, and back-dropped by Neil Armstrong’s moon landing and Woodstock. Goldwyn’s very talented screenwriter then was Pamela Gray, and she also wrote Conviction, which has some of the same qualities, the same laser eye on part-dysfunctional but loving families, the same sure structure, the same kind of meaty roles. I’m sure all the actors were glad that her name, and her words, were on the page. Thanks to Gray and all of them, and thanks above all to Betty-Anne Waters, this is a bio-drama full of feeling, strength and the right sense of justice.

Except for one thing.

SPOILER ALERT (seriously, this time).

Roger Ebert brings up something important in his review, that had puzzled me, and that may actually be a notable script flaw. In the final pre-credits notes, we learn what happened to the main characters, but not what happened to Kenny. According to Roger, Betty Anne’s brother died in an accident a half-year or so after being released from jail, while going over a high wall on the way to his mother’s house.

When I read this, I was stunned. Why in the world wasn’t this information in the movie? Was it cut out of the script, or the film? Was it nixed by some exec with a rulebook and a happy-ending fetish? It’s hard for me to believe that Goldwyn and Gray would have wanted that scene, or even just at mention in the crawl, deleted — or that Rockwell and Swank would want it gone either.

Doesn’t anybody in power realize what a potentially great sequence they threw away (Kenny saying goodbye, and then Kenny taking the leap, falling, dying), what an unforgettable piece of real-life drama and irony they just ignored? The ending right now in Conviction is a piece of more conventional uplift. The real-life ending (if that’s it) just rips your heart out, tears your guts open — besides reinforcing and driving home as strongly as possible the movie’s core theme of injustice, and of how it can ruin lives, and why it’s so necessary to fight it every chance you get.

By the way, Peter Neufeld, of Neufeld and Scheck, and the Innocence Project, is an old college friend of mine, and a fellow movie buff; I once tried to get him a spot on the UW Memorial Union Film Committee, with Joe McBride, Gerry and Danny Peary and the rest of us. Now, I’d just like to thank him and his partner Barry for the incredibly good jobs they keep doing. And thanks too to all the people who made Conviction, for the good work they did here as well, in this picture, in this heartfelt story. They really meant it; we can tell.

__________________________________________________

Certified Copy (Four Stars)

France/Italy/Iran: Abbas Kiarostami, 2010

My favorite film of the festival so far is Kiarostami’s first non-Iranian production, a jewel of that director‘s special brand of stylized cinema realism, and a meditation (like Orson WellesF for Fake) on artistry and fakery.

Shot in Italy (seedbed of neo-realism, homeland of Rossellini and De Sica), starring a French leading lady (Juliette Binoche) and an English leading man (William Shirnell), this splendidly shot (by Luca Bigazzi) European/Iranian co-production is partly one of Abbas Kiarostami’s chamber road movies — one of those Kiarostami pictures in which much of the action and dialogue transpire in a traveling car’s front seat between characters in the driver and passenger sides — and partly a pastiche of Rossellini’s great but controversial 1953 romantic travelogue drama Voyage in Italy (or Strangers), with Ingrid Bergman and George Sanders as a couple on vacation whose marriage is crumbling.

The setting, as with the recent arty George Clooney thriller The American, is on the roads and in the mountain villages of provincial Italy. Shirnell (an opera star) plays James Miller, an opinionated and somewhat self-absorbed best-selling author, who has just written a best-seller on the validity of artistic or painterly copying. Binoche is an unnamed single mother who takes Miller on a day date and drive in the country, and who likes to argue and provoke and meet new people.

Somewhere along the way the two begin impersonating a married couple (with problems, like Bergman and Sanders), and they slide into their roles with strange, unexplained fullness. The movie is enigmatic, and full of talk and ideas, but it also feels as natural as breathing. Akira Kurosawa, expressing his sorrow at the death of Satyajit Ray, named Kiarostami as Ray’s obvious successor, and Certified Copy recalls late Ray (The Home and the World), in its beauty and psychology. Kiarostami though, is one of a kind. He‘s really like no one else, even when he makes a copy of someone like Rossellini. (In Italian, French and English with English subtitles.) (Chicago Film Festival)

__________________________________________________

Thunder Soul (Three and a Half Stars)

U. S.; Mark Landsman, 2010

Conrad “Prof” Johnson was a great teacher who inspired his students, created something marvelous, was treated very badly by the system, but who here, in this film, near the end of his life, got his due and received a glorious tribute from his students. The Prof was a high school music teacher of extraordinary talent and skill. He was a local legend who turned his Texas high school student orchestra, the Kashmere Stage Band, into a top-notch funk outfit that gave tremendous concerts, won every local and national award in sight in its ‘70s heyday, and produced funk music records that were dynamic, terrific and equal to the products of the best professional bands of the era. His students loved him, his city loved him, and the world loved his band and his music.

Then the Prof got ensnared in bureaucracy and office politics. A new Kashmere school administration, and the local education establishment, composed apparently of too many jerks, jealous jack-asses and pompous meddling fools, harassed him, drove him out, and ruined the unique program he created. He’s a sweet man, and it looks like he didn’t fight back, just walked away. By the time we pick up the story, now, decades later, the entire school is sunk in mediocrity, and on the verge of collapse.

So the Prof’s ex-students from the Kashmere Band’s great ’70s heyday, decide to come back, get together, reform the band, and put on a last concert for the Prof. It isn’t easy. Some of them are working professionals, but some haven’t picked up their instrument for years. The Prof is 92, sick, and, as the concert approaches, he suffers a heart attack and has to be hospitalized. But when the spirit is moved, the soul will find a way. I defy you not to be deeply moved by the last scenes of this movie — a picture that shows how much you can do with a tiny budget, one camera and a great, great story. This is one wonderful documentary/concert film, and my only complaint is that it left me wanting more.

No — I’ve got another carp. The sabotage of the Prof’s program and of his band is an inexcusable, infuriating episode, and I want to know the names of the swine who wrecked that program and destroyed the beauty and art that this fine, gifted man and his gifted, loving students created — and I want to know why the local powers did it, the political dirt, the story behind it all. Director Mark Landsman knows, but he sort of slides by it; you get the impression he thinks it’s too hurtful to dwell on, that he just wants to shine a light on the Prof’s shining hour. He does, and as you watch the Kashmere Stage Band‘s Farewell Concert for their leader, the anger abates and you think: God bless great teachers like the Prof. They’re really heroes. (Chicago Film Festival)

__________________________________________________

Bitter Feast (Two Stars)

U. S.; Joe Maggio, 2010

A vain, heartless star chef and TV show cook/host named Peter Grey (James LeGros) gets trashed in a New York City blog by a mean critic named J. T. Franks (Joshua Leonard), which costs Grey all his jobs and destroys his career. Incensed, Grey kidnaps the nasty little blogger/critic, ties him up in the cellar in his isolated mansion in the woods, and proceeds to torment him with sadistic cooking lessons (forcing him to make an egg over easy or a perfect medium rare filet mignon) that turn into real torture.

I thought this one was going to be tasteless but funny. Instead it’s tasteless, unfunny and frequently ridiculous. One blogger, with a reputation for hating everything he reviews, has this much power? Come on. And what kind of idiot would invent torture games based on making eggs over easy? It would have been funnier if they‘d both been forced to eat the chef‘s increasingly vile dishes — which could have been Baby Jane Hudson kind of culinary rat and bug concoctions — and then write reviews on the spot saying that they‘re wonderful, tantalizing, four or five star stuff. But director-writer Maggio seems hung up on the idea that critics can’t do what they criticize. That may be true, but it’s not particularly funny or frightening.

Bitter Feast is not badly shot, but it’s weakly, over-obviously written. Horror director (and this film’s co producer) Larry Fessenden shows up and behaves very stupidly as a sleazy Dennis Franz sort of private eye, and Amy Seimetz, as J. T.’s more compassionate wife, gets tied up in the cellar too. Still, the whole thing struck me as about as scary as a fallen soufflé. But please…This may be a blog, and I may be sometimes mean, but I don’t want to be kidnapped, tied up in a cellar and forced to watch this movie and The Human Centipede — and maybe even remake them — over and over again. (Chicago Film Festival)

__________________________________________________

Circus Kids (Three Stars)

Israel/U.S.A.: Alexandra Lipsitz, 2001

Circus acrobatics cross all boundaries. Or so it seems in this good, lively documentary about a racially and socially diverse St. Louis Kids‘ circus troupe, Circus Harmony‘s St. Louis Arches, who travel to Israel to join hands and do back-flips with a mixed troupe of Jewish and Arab kids in Israel. The message is obvious, but that doesn’t mean it doesn’t get delivered. The only thing this movie really needs is more circus acts. (Extras on the DVD, maybe?) Director Alexandra Lipsitz does a fine job throughout, and she’s also a really excellent cinematographer. (In English and Hebrew, with English subtitles.) (Chicago Film Festival)

__________________________________________________

Uncle Boonmee, Who Can Recall His Past Lives (Three and a Half Stars)
Thailand; Apichatpong Weerasethakul, 2010

“Call me Joe,” Apichatpong Weerasethakul told me when I met him at a dinner at the 2004 Cannes Film Festival, and I couldn’t have guessed then that, within a few years, this trail-blazing, friendly young Thai filmmaker would have won the Cannes Palme d’Or — as he did this year with “Uncle Boonmee…:” I’m happy for Thailand, happy for Joe, who’s now made the kind of international breakthrough Akira Kurosawa once made for Japanese cinema, Satyajit Ray once made for India, and Tran Anh Hung for Vietnam. He’s put his country on the cinematic map.

Uncle Boonmee is a beautiful little film about what it means to die, or to watch a family member die. The central character, Boonmee (Yukantorn Mingmongkan) is a farmer in the Thai countryside, dying of kidney disease. His family gathers around him. So do his ghosts, including the spirit of his dead wife and his son, who has become a “monkey ghost.” No one is too shocked or unsettled by the appearance of the ghosts; they’re just another part of the family. And death, the film says quietly and touchingly, is just another part of life.

Much of Uncle Boonmee… is shot at night, in the gentle enveloping dark, or in the hazy green brightness of the day, or in a cave where the family wanders, or the church where Boonmee gets his last farewell. Before he dies, he tries to make peace with everyone, even worrying about “all the Communists” he killed for the government. Then he’s gone. So will all of us, and all those we love or hate or simply know.

I don’t know that I would have given Uncle Boonmee the Palme d‘Or. Joe’s visual style is a little rough and hazy for me, though maybe that’s Thailand. But Joe is a devotee of the American underground (Warhol, Baillie) and he’s not trying for the visual sophistication of either American mainstream movies or a Kurosawa, a Ray, or even a Tran Anh Hung. He’s telling his story, a Thai family’s story, a tale of life and death and how they interpenetrate each other. And this is life, this is cinema. (In Thai and French, with English subtitles.) (Chicago Film Festival)

__________________________________________________

Copacabana (Two and a Half Stars)

France/Belgium: Marc Fitousi, 2010

Isabelle Huppert is one of the greatest living movie actresses, no doubt about it. And her performance as a footloose, Bohemian, counter-culture mother, Babou — whose more establishment-oriented daughter Esmeralda is too embarrassed by her mom’s endless antics to invite her to her wedding with her bourgeois in-laws-to-be (Shame, Esmeralda!), driving Babou to try to turn a late leaf and settle down as a real-estate time share agent — is vintage Huppert: saucy, alive, bemused, totally real.

The film though has some twists that make little sense, even given Babou’s reckless nature, and the visual/cinematographic style is a bit bland and fuzzy. Bravo Huppert though. Babou and Copacabana may let us down, but Huppert never. (In French, English and Flemish, with English subtitles.) (Chicago Film Festival)

__________________________________________________

Hitler in Hollywood (Two and a Half Stars)

Belgium/France: Frederic Sachjer, 2010

A playful mockumentary in which on-camera investigator Maria de Medeiros, filming a tribute documentary to legendary French actress Micheline Presle, uncovers a Fascist/C.I.A. plot to hamstring European cinema and inundate the continent with Hollywood trash. It’s a widespread plot; even legendary French cinematographer Raoul Coutard is indicted as a C. I. A. agent and Breathless and the whole Nouvelle Vague as a C. I. A. plot to wreck classical French movie-making.

As the elfin Pulp Fiction cutie-pie de Medeiros delves into the vast conspiracy — which starts to unravel when Presle reveals the existence of a lost 1939 Presle film, directed by the mysterious moviemaker/mogul Luis Aramcheck (who also, they tell us here, made another post-war film called “Hitler in Hollywood” and tried vainly to combat the C. I. A./Hollywood plotters) — she has to cope with film partners who keep quitting, a cinematographer in love with her, and the plotters themselves, who are now hot on her trail.

Obviously, this film, shot imitation verite/documentary style, is a cinephile’s playful goof. And director Sachjer spiffs it up by taking us to the Cannes Film Festival (where de Medeiros interviews ex-Cannes head Gilles Jacob), and dropping in cameos with European cineastes Volker Schlondorff, Wim Wenders, and Emir Kusturica, and actresses Nathalie Baye and Arielle Dombasle.

The last person she interviews is her great fellow Portuguese moviemaker and Cannes mainstay, Manoel de Oliveira, still making films after turning 100 in 2008. Presle by the way, who’s 88 herself, still holds the camera as she did when she played the older woman to Gerard Philipe in the 1947 erotic classic Devil in the Flesh. How can Hollywood compete with that? (In French, English and Portuguese, with English subtitles.)