By Ray Pride Pride@moviecitynews.com
N for Neocon: Wolcott susses Denby's shushing
While I’m awaiting a Wednesday night second viewing in IMAX before frying my bacon over the ultra-crispy V for Vendetta, James Wolcott offers a tart aside to the most goombah of early reviews, with the New Yorker’s august David Denby partaking in the aborning controversy over the movie’s mere existence: “It’s been awhile since we’ve had a truly critically divisive movie, and V for Vendetta is shaping up to be it. As David Poland writes in The Hot Blog, the next week or so promises to be an interesting ride for this film, with reviewers already declaring their opinions as “facts” as they try to dampen down expectations and excitement. Beware of professions of boredom when the subject and execution are this controversial. I anticipated that my Upper West Side neighbor David Denby—such a trial for him, bumping into me wherever he goes—would render a negative verdict on V for Vendetta, and so he does, rapping his gavel with stern monotonony… With this review and his pan of Why We Fight, I fear David is drifting toward neoconservatism, a doctrine more congenial to the sort of principled stands he likes to take, offering more room for rhetorical heroism. I pray I am wrong.” [It’s probably important to recall that Mr. Denby was making such invocations as far back as Do The Right Thing from his elevated step-stool at New York magazine. Of that movie’s incendiary finale, Denby wrote, “Lee appears to be endorsing the outcome, and if some audiences go wild, he’s partly responsible.”]
Denby’s one of those sensitive and astute critics who realized that in Spike Lee’s Do The Right Thing, Mookie tossing a garbage can through a window was far more tragic and incendiary than the cops’ killing of Radio Raheem.
Property Damage > Human Life
That’s why he’s a legend!
In the late 90’s I managed the foreign film section of a video store on the Upper West Side of Manhattan. Denby was one of our members. He stopped in the day after he went to the preview of Spike Lee’s “Do The Right Thing” and said that the film was irresponsible and would cause Black people to riot in NYC. Now, this was at a time when cops were beating and shooting Black people quite regularly and there hadn’t been any riots so I asked David, “do you really think that considering the state of relations between Blacks and the cops in NY that Black people need a movie to make them riot? Aren’t the current state of affairs more than enough?”. He stared at me a moment, took his rental video (I wish I remembered what it was) and walked out. We didn’t talk much after that. Interestingly, all of the racial violence from that summer was directed towards Blacks…especially a few instances that occured in predominantly Italian sections of Brooklyn…and there were no riots from Blacks about it.